The ancient lands.


5 posters

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Poll

    Anyone else agree?

    [ 3 ]
    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Bar_le1150%Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Bar_ri11 [50%] 
    [ 3 ]
    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Bar_le1150%Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Bar_ri11 [50%] 

    Total Votes: 6
    sykog
    sykog

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Imagee10


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Blackr10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalw11Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalg10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Zigzag10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medal13

      : Male
     Rep29

    Age: : 29
     Posts: : 8839

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by sykog August 21st 2009, 9:36 pm

    I was figuring that we could have this forum so that the videogame Sonic forum won't be so cluttered and maybe we could also gt a bit more discussion from having a more specific forum.
    NeoMetalSonic
    NeoMetalSonic

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Imagee10


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Blackr10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalw11Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Zigzag10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games White10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medal13Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalg10

      : Male
     Rep35

    Age: : 30
     Posts: : 5131

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by NeoMetalSonic August 21st 2009, 9:52 pm

    No
    Plix
    Plix

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games VOZLn


      : Male
     Rep13

     Posts: : 2080

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by Plix August 21st 2009, 11:01 pm

    Only on one condition: ASR doesn't get its own board. It's a SEGA game, not a SONIC game. Only M&S should get its own board for now, and when new games are announced, they should get one.
    The Freedom Fighter
    The Freedom Fighter

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games ZtZYh


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Blackr10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalw11Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Zigzag10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games White10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medal13Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games 2nio02t

      : Male
     Rep76

    Age: : 34
     Posts: : 5812

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by The Freedom Fighter August 21st 2009, 11:29 pm

    I don't think we were making more boards, were we? I thought just another forum to discuss new games.
    But whatever, fine; although, technically, both games are half Sonic games.
    sykog
    sykog

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Imagee10


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Blackr10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalw11Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalg10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Zigzag10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medal13

      : Male
     Rep29

    Age: : 29
     Posts: : 8839

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by sykog August 22nd 2009, 12:46 am

    SupaSEGA wrote:Only on one condition: ASR doesn't get its own board. It's a SEGA game, not a SONIC game. Only M&S should get its own board for now, and when new games are announced, they should get one.
    Sure thing.
    Plix
    Plix

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games VOZLn


      : Male
     Rep13

     Posts: : 2080

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by Plix August 22nd 2009, 11:31 pm

    ASR is no more a Sonic game than the UGC. His name is only tagged on for sales. In Europe, SUGC was called SEGA Mega Drive Ultimate Collection. Also, ASR is considered by both SEGA and Sumo to be the sequel to SST, which is also not a Sonic game.


    If you consider ASR a Sonic game, then consider Brawl a Sonic game. Only ASR has a few more characters.
    The Freedom Fighter
    The Freedom Fighter

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games ZtZYh


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Blackr10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalw11Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Zigzag10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games White10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medal13Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games 2nio02t

      : Male
     Rep76

    Age: : 34
     Posts: : 5812

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by The Freedom Fighter August 22nd 2009, 11:45 pm

    SupaSEGA wrote:ASR is no more a Sonic game than the UGC. His name is only tagged on for sales. In Europe, SUGC was called SEGA Mega Drive Ultimate Collection. Also, ASR is considered by both SEGA and Sumo to be the sequel to SST, which is also not a Sonic game.


    If you consider ASR a Sonic game, then consider Brawl a Sonic game. Only ASR has a few more characters.
    Yes, and Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine was Puyo Pop something. But DRMBM is a Sonic game, even if it went under much more revisions.
    And I wouldn't, because Sonic's cast is outnumbered in Brawl, he isn't a main character, and he isn't in the title.
    Plix
    Plix

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games VOZLn


      : Male
     Rep13

     Posts: : 2080

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by Plix August 23rd 2009, 12:15 am

    Mean Bean Machine was a Puyo Pop clone...not a smash up of characters from different games like SST, ASR, and Brawl are. Sonic's cast is outnumbered in ASR by SEGA characters, and none of the Sonic characters are main, everyone is. Sonic is only tacked on for sales, much like Ultimate Genesis Collection. Is that a Sonic game? No.
    Erazor
    Erazor

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Imagee10


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Blackr10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalw11Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalg10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games White10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medal13

      : Male
     Rep22

     Posts: : 2153

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by Erazor August 23rd 2009, 1:03 am

    If there are going to be arguments about whether or not it's a Sonic game then just screw the whole idea. One thing the Sega boards do right is not give a damn about what you're discussing in the Sonic boards, so long as it's remotely related to Sonic. Besides, if all we're going to talk about in that section is Mario & Sonic @ the Winter Olympics the idea is pretty much pointless. There's only so many topics you can have on a crappy sports spinoff.

    I also don't see why it can't just be a sub-forum under Video Games. Even if it was, I'm still opposed to the idea.
    Plix
    Plix

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games VOZLn


      : Male
     Rep13

     Posts: : 2080

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by Plix August 23rd 2009, 4:46 pm

    M&S Winer Olympics is shaping up to be much better than its predecessor.
    sykog
    sykog

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Imagee10


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Blackr10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalw11Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalg10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Zigzag10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medal13

      : Male
     Rep29

    Age: : 29
     Posts: : 8839

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by sykog August 23rd 2009, 7:10 pm

    SupaSEGA wrote:M&S Winer Olympics is shaping up to be much better than its predecessor.
    What' wrong with the predecessor?
    Plix
    Plix

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games VOZLn


      : Male
     Rep13

     Posts: : 2080

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by Plix August 23rd 2009, 10:47 pm

    I didn't think it was a bad game, I was just talking to Erazor. But Winter Olympics is looking to be more entertaining.
    sykog
    sykog

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Imagee10


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Blackr10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalw11Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medalg10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Zigzag10Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Medal13

      : Male
     Rep29

    Age: : 29
     Posts: : 8839

    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by sykog August 23rd 2009, 11:42 pm

    Right now the opinions are too mixed, so it probably wont happen, but if anyone really wants it, please tell why.

    Sponsored content


    Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games Empty Re: Upcoming/Newly released Sonic games

    Post by Sponsored content