Secret Rings vs. Black Knight

My chit-chat in that graphics topic gave me the idea for this thread. If there's a topic already well too bad. Basically just pick which Wii exclusive adventure you prefer.

I prefer Secret Rings overall. I like the art design, music, gameplay, multiplayer, and characters more than Black Knight's.

Never really played any of them which is weird since I have a Wii

That is weird. I recommend trying them. I'm not too fond of Black Knight but I'm not one to let my own opinion get in the way of someone trying a game out.

I'd definitley say that Secret Rings is worth more than the 20$ it currently costs though.

Erazor wrote:I prefer Secret Rings overall. I like the art design, music, gameplay, multiplayer, and characters more than Black Knight's.

Pretty much the opposite. I like the art, music, gameplay, story, characters, and overall design more. I haven't tried S&TBK's multiplayer yet though.

The Freedom Fighter wrote:

Erazor wrote:I prefer Secret Rings overall. I like the art design, music, gameplay, multiplayer, and characters more than Black Knight's.

Pretty much the opposite. I like the art, music, gameplay, story, characters, and overall design more. I haven't tried S&TBK's multiplayer yet though.

I find it to be a bit repetitive. It can be fun when you have at least 3 people though. The "kill as many enemies as possible" game modes aren't too fun but the ones where you kill eachother are a blast.

I rather have SatBK tbh.

I prefer The Blank Knight.

I like Black Knight a little better.

black knight is best sonic game so far. good music, good story, no overload of characters and more CG-I cutscenes

I would say Black Knight is better, ever so slightly.

Kriegsmarine wrote:black knight is best sonic game so far. good music, good story, no overload of characters and more CG-I cutscenes

Not true....it's a decent Sonic game, but not the best. I don't think that Swords go along with Sonic.

Mr. Fit wrote:

Kriegsmarine wrote:black knight is best sonic game so far. good music, good story, no overload of characters and more CG-I cutscenes

Not true....it's a decent Sonic game, but not the best. I don't think that Swords go along with Sonic.

our opinions clash mr. fit

prepeare to have a flame war!!
i mean....
uhhh....

I choose Black Knight. Even if I can't play the freaking multiplayer.

Crystal Chaotix 3 wrote:I choose Black Knight. Even if I can't play the freaking multiplayer.

Don't worry, it sucks anyways. You aren't missing out on anything. The characters move about 2mph on tiny little stages.

sykog77 wrote:

Crystal Chaotix 3 wrote:I choose Black Knight. Even if I can't play the freaking multiplayer.

Don't worry, it sucks anyways. You aren't missing out on anything. The characters move about 2mph on tiny little stages.

I wouldn't think it sucks. I hardly think anything sucks.

And even if it did I don't want to miss out on a chance to play as all those guys. I AM missing out damnit!

I WANNA PLAY IT

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-PGMyg5hY04

I prefer Secret Rings. I thought Black Knight was terrible

I prefer Black Knight.

I've never even played SatBK and I can almost positively tell you I'll like it less than SatSR.
SatSR wasn't too bad for a newer Sonic game, it was better than Sonic Unleashed that's for sure.
I've watched a few SatBK cutscenes and it looks terrible, I don't like the idea of using a sword for a start, plus it looks way too grey and dull for my liking.

Unleashed will always be better then both those games. And no, it's not because I can't beat Erazor.

Crystal Chaotix 3 wrote:Unleashed will always be better then both those games. And no, it's not because I can't beat Erazor.

I really thought the boss battle with Erazor was the best part. In fact, I really enjoyed all of the bosses in that game (except Alf-Layla-Wa-Layla). But you're right, overall Secret Rings can't compare to Unleashed.

The Black Knight for me.

I had such horrible problems with the controls in Secret Rings. And I found it boring overall.