The Sonic Tournament: Best Sonic Spinoff

Which Sonic game do you find to be the best spinoff Sonic Game?

You can discuss why and who you picked, too.

This tournament has been divided into 4 categories, as seen from the 4 topics.

After all of the rounds are completed, then one category will go up against the other.

In other words, these are the prelims. Then it'll go into semifinals, and then finals.

How is Sonic CD a spin off?

ProTagOnist wrote:How is Sonic CD a spin off?

Sorry, fixing that.

You have Sonic Party twice.
I don't know the categories.
I voted for Shadow the Hedgehog.
Reason: It incoperates itself with a character with a unique spin to the series. It actually makes sense in the canon, too!

I'm voting Sonic and the Secret Rings.

Why is ASR on the poll when it is NOT a Sonic game?

Neither is SEGA Superstars Tennis, which you have listed as a totally different name.

SupaSEGA wrote:Why is ASR on the poll when it is NOT a Sonic game?

Neither is SEGA Superstars Tennis, which you have listed as a totally different name.

Well, it had Sonic in the name, so........

And I messed up on the Tennis part. Sorry.

SonicFanPS2 wrote:

SupaSEGA wrote:Why is ASR on the poll when it is NOT a Sonic game?

Well, it had Sonic in the name, so........

Finally someone thinks about it the same way I do. :mrgreen: Still, I'd only call it half a Sonic game, but whatever.

sykog77 wrote:I'm voting Sonic and the Secret Rings.

Me too. Good stuff right there.

SupaSEGA wrote:Why is ASR on the poll when it is NOT a Sonic game?

Could have fooled me.

ASR. Great game

I voted for Sonic 3D Blast, because it gets too much hate. It wasn't that bad. Sure, the view got annoying at times, but it added it's own difficulty to it. Hell, without it, the game may have been too easy.

Votes end in a few days, guys.

It also has Banjo Kazooie in the title, is it a Banjo Kazooie game as well?

It was tacked on for sales, that's it. Not a Sonic game.

And SEGA All Stars Tennis never had Sonic even in the name, so why is it still on there?



This is like saying Brawl is a Sonic game because Sonic is in it. Or that a movie soundtrack should be contributed to only one artist because they have the majority of the songs on the disc. It's just bad logic.

SupaSEGA wrote:It also has Banjo Kazooie in the title, is it a Banjo Kazooie game as well?

It was tacked on for sales, that's it. Not a Sonic game.

And SEGA All Stars Tennis never had Sonic even in the name, so why is it still on there?



This is like saying Brawl is a Sonic game because Sonic is in it. Or that a movie soundtrack should be contributed to only one artist because they have the majority of the songs on the disc. It's just bad logic.

I just thought it could also boost up the competition in this poll.

And SEGA All Stars Tennis was a mistake, which I thank you for pointing out. However, I can't fix it since people already started voting.

I didn't mean to make such mistakes on the poll. Sorry.

SupaSEGA wrote:It also has Banjo Kazooie in the title, is it a Banjo Kazooie game as well?

It was tacked on for sales, that's it. Not a Sonic game.

Banjo's not in the title, does not have the main focus or mascot status of Sega, nor does his cast make up a major portion of the roster. Sonic's does. This is why it's half a Sonic game. Your only reason seems to be that it was just a sales ploy.

Go Sonic R.

SupaSEGA wrote:This is like saying Brawl is a Sonic game because Sonic is in it. Or that a movie soundtrack should be contributed to only one artist because they have the majority of the songs on the disc. It's just bad logic.

That's funny because it's not like that at all.

Sonic and the Black Knight is, in my opinion, the best Sonic Spinoff

The gameplay and graphics and stuff are just generally quite good

Erazor wrote:

SupaSEGA wrote:This is like saying Brawl is a Sonic game because Sonic is in it. Or that a movie soundtrack should be contributed to only one artist because they have the majority of the songs on the disc. It's just bad logic.

That's funny because it's not like that at all.

So Sonic characters hold more spots than any other franchise's characters in the game (say a soundtrack has the same amount of songs as ASR has characters, and the same amount of Sonic characters in ASR is the same amount of songs that a band did for the album). Thus, ASR is a Sonic game and that soundtrack is the band's album only.

The characters are like tracks.

That's funny, it makes sense. :/

Alright! Today's the last of the tournament! Make sure to get your votes in! Votes finish at 6 PM Central Time!

Black Knight has more than one vote? What has this world come to?

Erazor wrote:Black Knight has more than one vote? What has this world come to?

Some people just like to vote for the most recent game, and haven't playing ASR.

sykog77 wrote:

Erazor wrote:Black Knight has more than one vote? What has this world come to?

Some people just like to vote for the most recent game, and haven't been playing ASR.

Courtesy of your friendly neighborhood grammar Nazi.