by The Freedom Fighter May 1st 2011, 4:45 pm
Graphics: Good, but not as great as the originals. I really wish they would have went with sprites, sprites need the love and attention.
Music: The Wii version has the superior music for me, crazily enough. When I first heard the music in HD, I wasn't impressed. Then I got the Wii version, and everything felt more natural and likable. This has led me to liking the HD music a bit better now, but Wii still stand triumphant.
Characters: With only two real characters, it's incredibly important to not screw up. Eggman is fine, although they could have had him emote more, but oh well. Sonic has lost his impatient emote, but he does still retain his character anyway, so no worries.
Story: Incredibly weak, even by old-school standards. Sonic's on vacation, Eggman wants vengeance, but has a budget to follow, which weakens almost all badniks and Egg-O-Matics. And the island happens to be a Tails Co. rocket silo home.
Gameplay: Despite physics issues, very well done. Everything seems to work well, and this game's Super Sonic is the most fun I've ever had as him. The level design is mostly good, except it may be the Sonic game with the least amount of extra paths yet, and there are too many Homing Attack Bridges and bottomless pits being back-to-back.