The ancient lands.


+13
LockerKnot
Sweet_Savannah_Charmy
Schnickelfritz
Plix
Mighty
sykog
Chaos_Overlord
SonicFanPS2
TheShadowWalker
Erazor
Superdoodleman
Jmh
BlasterForceXtreme
17 posters

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Poll

    What better?

    [ 11 ]
    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Bar_le1161%Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Bar_ri11 [61%] 
    [ 6 ]
    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Bar_le1133%Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Bar_ri11 [33%] 
    [ 1 ]
    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Bar_le116%Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Bar_ri11 [6%] 
    [ 0 ]
    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Bar_le110%Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Bar_ri11 [0%] 

    Total Votes: 18
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 11th 2010, 9:23 pm

    Sonic Adventure 1 is better.
    Super Mario 64 is cool, but not as cool.
    Jmh
    Jmh

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Imagee10


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 White10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep67

    Age: : 29
     Posts: : 7103

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Jmh March 11th 2010, 9:26 pm

    I personally prefer Super Mario 64.
    avatar
    Superdoodleman

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 GOMM8


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep0

     Posts: : 859

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Superdoodleman March 11th 2010, 9:32 pm

    Mario 64 DS isn't on there.
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 11th 2010, 9:58 pm

    wrote:Mario 64 DS isn't on there.

    If Mario 64 DS would be on, then by that logic, so should the inferior version of SA1, SADX. So no.

    Also the ports can count in their original formats here.
    Erazor
    Erazor

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Imagee10


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Blackr10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalg10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 White10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep22

     Posts: : 2153

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Erazor March 11th 2010, 10:02 pm

    Sonic Adventure. In terms of overall content, they're about even, but Sonic Adventure has the advantages of more characters, more variety, better music, better graphics, better story, and significantly more voice acting.
    TheShadowWalker
    TheShadowWalker

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 VOZLn


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalg10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 2hygec

      : Male
     Rep3

    Age: : 29
     Posts: : 2366

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by TheShadowWalker March 11th 2010, 10:45 pm

    Sonic Adventure.
    I actually beat it. SM64 is great and all, but I got sick of it after awhile.
    Sonic, I never will get sick of.
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 11th 2010, 10:46 pm

    And Sonic Adventure 1 is the easier game to pick up and play. Super Mario 64 is overly complex for that.
    Erazor
    Erazor

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Imagee10


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Blackr10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalg10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 White10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep22

     Posts: : 2153

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Erazor March 11th 2010, 10:48 pm

    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:And Sonic Adventure 1 is the easier game to pick up and play. Super Mario 64 is overly complex for that.
    Let's not forget the reason why half of the N64's games are difficult to pick up and play.
    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 N64-controller
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 11th 2010, 10:49 pm

    Actually the controller was pretty badass.
    Erazor
    Erazor

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Imagee10


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Blackr10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalg10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 White10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep22

     Posts: : 2153

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Erazor March 11th 2010, 10:51 pm

    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:Actually the controller was pretty badass.
    In appearance, yes. But, It really only worked well with the seriously deformed. I swear to god, half of my collection is almost unplayable.
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 11th 2010, 10:54 pm

    Well, the controller functions most like other controllers, they just placed the Joystick in a different position. But it goes out pretty cool if you ask me.
    avatar
    Superdoodleman

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 GOMM8


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep0

     Posts: : 859

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Superdoodleman March 12th 2010, 11:13 am

    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:Well, the controller functions most like other controllers, they just placed the Joystick in a different position. But it goes out pretty cool if you ask me.
    FINALLY
    Someone who actually LIKED that controller.
    I think it was made mainly for people with big hands.
    I'm voting for Mario 64. Mainly cause 64 DS isn't on there. 64 DS has 3 times the content of 64 and SA combined.
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 12th 2010, 11:37 am

    Sonic Adventure 1 has more content.
    avatar
    Superdoodleman

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 GOMM8


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep0

     Posts: : 859

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Superdoodleman March 12th 2010, 11:41 am

    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:Sonic Adventure 1 has more content.
    Eh. 64 DS Adds 3 new characters and 30 new stars. As well as Collectible rabbits, Enhanced graphics and minigames.
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 12th 2010, 11:43 am

    Sonic Adventure 1 had 7 playable characters, better graphics, VMU features, Internet features, Chao Gardens, Hubworlds, and played better.
    avatar
    Superdoodleman

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 GOMM8


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep0

     Posts: : 859

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Superdoodleman March 12th 2010, 11:51 am

    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:Sonic Adventure 1 had 7 playable characters, better graphics, VMU features, Internet features, Chao Gardens, Hubworlds, and played better.
    It had 6 playable characters and Super Sonic. The graphics were supirior to original's, But not 64 DS, No clue wht VMU is, Don't really care about internet or Chao, Mario had a hub worl and much less linear levels, And the last one is debatable.
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 12th 2010, 12:10 pm

    The graphics of the original SA1 are superior to SADX.

    And if you don't know what a VMU is, then leave.
    SonicFanPS2
    SonicFanPS2

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 VOZLn


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep12

    Age: : 71
     Posts: : 2090

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by SonicFanPS2 March 12th 2010, 5:30 pm

    Don't forget the fact that DX had some Gamegear games in there too, if we're also talking about the ports.


    Last edited by SonicFanPS2 on March 12th 2010, 5:32 pm; edited 1 time in total
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 12th 2010, 5:32 pm

    No, those were GameGear games. And those don't really count, because those are DIFFERENT games.
    SonicFanPS2
    SonicFanPS2

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 VOZLn


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep12

    Age: : 71
     Posts: : 2090

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by SonicFanPS2 March 12th 2010, 5:37 pm

    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:No, those were GameGear games. And those don't really count, because those are DIFFERENT games.

    Gamegear games, I apologize. And don't they, since they're basically the same content + new stuff?

    Plus, Sonic Adventure, since it featured a hub world, had about 9-10 stages that were able to be changed 6 times for 6 characters! I admit, Big's stages were horrible. But he himself wasn't too bad.

    However, Super Mario 64's world didn't change at all with their worlds. They instead kept changing the missions constantly, like in Sunshine. And you had to get so many stars to actually beat the final boss. That wasn't really fun. A bit too repetitive, to be honest. Though, this is for the DS version, seeing as I never played the 64 version.

    I like Galaxy though. That was awesome. I also agree that the controller for the 64 was extremely fun to play.


    Last edited by SonicFanPS2 on March 12th 2010, 7:44 pm; edited 1 time in total
    Chaos_Overlord
    Chaos_Overlord

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 VOZLn


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep11

    Age: : 32
     Posts: : 1633

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Chaos_Overlord March 12th 2010, 5:37 pm

    As much as I like Adventure 1, I personally prefered SM64. That game sucked me in teh instant I played it.
    BlasterForceXtreme
    BlasterForceXtreme

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Kz2PK


      : Male
     Rep0

    Age: : 33
     Posts: : 258

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by BlasterForceXtreme March 12th 2010, 7:21 pm

    Big The Cat was awesome.
    SonicFanPS2
    SonicFanPS2

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 VOZLn


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep12

    Age: : 71
     Posts: : 2090

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by SonicFanPS2 March 12th 2010, 7:44 pm

    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:Big The Cat was awesome.

    I loved swimming in the water while using him. Eh, he was actually pretty fun. His stages weren't too bad.
    sykog
    sykog

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Imagee10


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Blackr10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalw11Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medalg10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Zigzag10Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep29

    Age: : 30
     Posts: : 8839

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by sykog March 12th 2010, 8:56 pm

    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:Actually the controller was pretty badass.
    No, it was terrible. I don't have 3 hands.
    avatar
    Superdoodleman

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 GOMM8


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Medal13

      : Male
     Rep0

     Posts: : 859

    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Superdoodleman March 12th 2010, 9:08 pm

    sykog77 wrote:
    BlasterForceXtreme wrote:Actually the controller was pretty badass.
    No, it was terrible. I don't have 3 hands.
    Which is why you don't ned to use the far left one but in a couple of games.

    Sponsored content


    Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64 Empty Re: Sonic Adventure 1 vs. Super Mario 64

    Post by Sponsored content