SA2B??

Would Shadow be better off if he stayed dead from SA2B?? I think so.

Well, at least for a few games. Or at least with a return that was graceful and fitting of his character. Although, had he actually been a robot clone of Shadow, that would have been a nice plot point, one that could give Shadow purpose, and maybe a nice lackey for Ivo.

He should have never been made

You can't escape the harsh stuff no matter where you go young CC3. Heheheheh.

But no. They probably could've found a better way to bring him back though.

Yes, definitely. Shadow's my least favourite character because of his current personality plus his annoying fanbase, but before that, back in SA2 he was a pretty decent character. I loved the storyline in SA2, I actually cried when he died and that's the way he should've stayed, dead. He'd of been a MUCH better character IMO if he'd of stayed like that. Sonic characters should die (and stay dead) once in a while, to me that's why Gamma's a decent character (well, I still don't like him), I like character deaths.

Except Gamma came back, like twice.

The Freedom Fighter wrote:Except Gamma came back, like twice.

But it wasn't the real Gamma, Chaos Gama had no personalty.

And Shadow being my second favorite character, it's hard to say yes, but I think him not being in those games after SA2 would've helped give some more spotlight to Tails and Knuckles.

I'm pretty sure he did have a personality.

The Freedom Fighter wrote:I'm pretty sure he did have a personality.

Not much. The original Gamma is loads better.

Maybe so, but that doesn't mean Chaos Gamma didn't have a personality.

The Freedom Fighter wrote:Maybe so, but that doesn't mean Chaos Gamma didn't have a personality.

Yeah he did, hateful and acted more like a Robot