5 Greatest Overall Games of 2009

Nominees:

Assassin's Creed II: Combining historical fact with robust, well-written fiction is tricky, but this epic action sequel handled it with loving care. The result? Benissimo.
Publisher: Ubisoft
Critics: 91%

Batman: Arkham Asylum: He might not be as sturdy as Superman or as nimble as Spidey, but the Caped Crusader's jaw-dropping jaunt through the loony bin trounces every other superhero game on the planet.
Publisher: Eidos Interactive/Warner Bros. Interactive
Critics: 91%

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2: Hear of it? The biggest game of 2009 is also one of its best. Even if you don't like shooters, you can't help but be impressed by its unrivaled graphics engine and spectacular set pieces.
Publisher: Activision
Critics: 94%

Dragon Age: Origins: Huge, addictive, and hugely addictive, this high-fantasy masterstroke from the artisans at Bioware is handily one of their best games. Considering their incredible track record, that's saying a lot.
Publisher: Electronic Arts
Critics: 91%

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves: If Indiana Jones were younger, cooler, funnier and able to withstand about a million more bullets, he'd be Nathan Drake. Looks incredible, plays even better.
Publisher: Sony
Critics: 96%


Out of those, which is the best?

Dragon Age Origins

Assasins Creed II

Batman: Arkham Asylum.

Modern Warfare 2

Haven't played any of them. Hope to play Assassin's Creed 2 soon, but I need to beat AC (1) first.

MW2 from me obviously.

Never played any of them.

Nor do I really plan to.

Batman was amazingly stellar. Though, Mark Hamil MADE that game. His voice work as the Joker rivals Heath Ledgers performance in the Dark Knight. The game was bone-crunchingly delightful.

Modern Warfare 2 is a must-play. You must play the campaign at least one time through. The multiplayer is a big meh, but the campaign is something ever gamer should play at least once.

I haven't played any of them.

I'm getting Batman for Christmas. I don't own any of the others though.

I have a bunch of games to choose from, but none of those.

Batman Arkham Asylum takes the cake out of that list. I had a feeling that before it went out that it would steal the show, and it did just that.

Assassin's Creed 2 is not bad but I still prefer Altair. I really like Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2. This is the kind of game that I would play the story mode repetitively without getting tired,

Batman: Arkham Asylum. I've only played it and MW2 of that list, but given my experience from playing AC1 and owning but not playing yet AC2, I think I can say it's Batman is my favorite. The other two I don't know if I'll ever play.

The super secret best game of 2009

Spoiler:

Erazor wrote:The super secret best game of 2009

Spoiler:

The image is broken

I haven't played any of those. I vote Mario and Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story.

to me Uncharted 2 is Pitfall with pretty images

So far:

1.- Batman
2.- Modern Warfare 2
3.- Assassin's Creed II

Well, Uncharted took ACII's place now.

TalkingObject wrote:

Erazor wrote:The super secret best game of 2009

Spoiler:

The image is broken

fixd