Brawl or Melee?

So, which one did you like better?

Both. It kinda depends. Sometimes, I prefer Brawl and tart playing a lot, but then I go to play Melee and like it more, or the other way around. They are both my favorite games of all time though.

Melee at first. Getting used to the weight issues was a pain at first, and I liked the old items better, but Brawl in the end proved more awesome to me. Though, both are still awesome, and if I ever get around to restarting my Smash Wars game, I'll start with Melee probably.

Melee was a far more technical game in every way, Brawl's gamplay was dumbed down for casual gamers and just has more features, although admittedly Brawl is slightly more balanced.

Brawl. More stuff and whatnot.

Brawl. They both weren't that great but Brawl had more stuff.

They're tied for me.

Brawl, because of Wario, Sonic, and Olimar.

Brwal cause Sonics in but Then again Melee was Good cause they had Roy :(:

Shadow Dude 64 wrote:Brwal cause Sonics in but Then again Melee was Good cause they had Roy :(:

And Young Link.

Brawl.

Melee, because Captain Falcon doesn't suck.

Brawl.

Brawl all 'cause of the storyline

Kriegsmarine wrote:Brawl all 'cause of the storyline

I thought that was pretty cool too.

Sunset wrote:They're tied for me.

Nevermind. This was before I had played Melee for the first time in years. After going back and playing it, I decided it was better than Brawl.

Oh, and the original was awesome too.

Melee. Brawl is a lot slower paced compared to its predecessor, and those stupid smash balls throw everything out of whack. Sonic's lasts over 15 seconds, and can kill nearly everything in its sight. Talk about unfair.

SupaSEGA wrote:Melee. Brawl is a lot slower paced compared to its predecessor, and those stupid smash balls throw everything out of whack. Sonic's lasts over 15 seconds, and can kill nearly everything in its sight. Talk about unfair.

you can turn them off. I do that sometimes.

Some things I feel Brawl has over Melee are:
- Better sound (music, voice work, sound effects, etc)
- Better Yoshi design
- Better Announcer
- "Clones" done better
- Return of classic on-screen appearances
- More unique characters

Melee. When it came out people played it for fun, what a game is supposed to be played for. Now with brawl out, it's all competitive, 'YOU SUK CUZ OF MK!!!!110', and more bitching overall.

I always do turn them off, because they throw the balance of the game off tenfold.

SupaSEGA wrote:I always do turn them off, because they throw the balance of the game off tenfold.

great either aint overkill It only kills people in an extremely powerful slashing kicking and launch off the the top of the scree...wait It is overkill....

SupaSEGA wrote:I always do turn them off, because they throw the balance of the game off tenfold.

i use them about half of the time.

sykog77 wrote:

SupaSEGA wrote:I always do turn them off, because they throw the balance of the game off tenfold.

i use them about half of the time.

I use Smash balls whenever I want.

I never turn items of any kind off. I don't play Smash for "balance". If I wanted that I'd play Tekken.