Least Favorite of these games?

Which of these retro Sonic games do you like the least or find overrated?

Chaosmaster8753 wrote:Which of these retro Sonic games do you like the least

Sonic 91.

Chaosmaster8753 wrote:or find overrated?

I don't find any of them to be horribly overrated, however, if I were to pick one out of that list, then, definitely Sonic 2.

I'd suggest making this poll multiple choice.

Zez wrote:I'd suggest making this poll multiple choice.

I did at first.

Chaosmaster8753 wrote:

Zez wrote:I'd suggest making this poll multiple choice.

I did at first.

I can't vote for Sonic 1 or Sonic 2. They're both "bad" in their own way.

Zez wrote:

Chaosmaster8753 wrote:

I did at first.

I can't vote for Sonic 1 or Sonic 2. They're both "bad" in their own way.

I just added multiple choice.

I vote for Sonic 1 and Sonic 2, as they are my least favourite games out of the options provided.

All we need is someone to vote for Sonic CD...

Auflodern wrote:All we need is someone to vote for Sonic CD...

I'd be glad to take that honor, as I thought Sonic CD was pretty mediocre compared to the rest.

Super Racer Z wrote:

Auflodern wrote:All we need is someone to vote for Sonic CD...

I'd be glad to take that honor, as I thought Sonic CD was pretty mediocre compared to the rest.

Oh yes, those near-OVA cut-scenes were in every Sonic game before and after it.

Sonic 1 :|

I really don't like that game.

Someone's trolling. There's a vote for S3&K.

Not too fond of the wording, but Sonic 1 is rather obsolete compared to its immediate sequels.

Zez wrote:

Super Racer Z wrote:

I'd be glad to take that honor, as I thought Sonic CD was pretty mediocre compared to the rest.

Oh yes, those near-OVA cut-scenes were in every Sonic game before and after it.

Cutscenes aren't gameplay.

You said Sonic CD, which implies the game as an entirety, is mediocre. You didn't specifically direct it towards gameplay. Cutscenes are still a part of the game, which helped it from being mediocre.

Zez wrote:You said Sonic CD, which implies the game as an entirety, is mediocre. You didn't specifically direct it towards gameplay. Cutscenes are still a part of the game, which helped it from being mediocre.

Mediocre compared to the other titles. IMO, I just thought the game wasn't as fun or enjoyable as the others. The level design just felt really off.

I love them all to death, but out of those, I would say Sonic The Hedgehog (1). I have played Sonic 1 the least, and being the first instalment, there are lots of things that could have been improved, which where obviously made when Sonic 2 came out. It's still a brilliant game and is a classic.

Super Racer Z wrote:

Zez wrote:You said Sonic CD, which implies the game as an entirety, is mediocre. You didn't specifically direct it towards gameplay. Cutscenes are still a part of the game, which helped it from being mediocre.

Mediocre compared to the other titles. IMO, I just thought the game wasn't as fun or enjoyable as the others. The level design just felt really off.

I'll always love Sonic CD. I was bought it as a kid when it came out on PC. I remember loading it into my Windows 95 system, and the game had some trouble to load because of the speed of the PC LOL. Good memories. I still have that PC game today, mainly becuase it has the soundtrack on it.

I wonder why people always say that Sonic CD was the best. I found it good...like an A (70-79).

Zez wrote:Someone's trolling. There's a vote for S3&K.

Oh f you
Some people actually DETEST that those games

Anyways
Sonic 1 and S3&K
Overrated games are overrated

NeoMetalSonic wrote:Oh f you

Because I made a joke, and like a game. Bravo. No prejudice at all.

NeoMetalSonic wrote:Some people actually DETEST that those games

1.- Proof.
2.- Who cares?
3.- "that those games" - That those games what? That those games are playable?

NeoMetalSonic wrote:Anyways
Sonic 1 and S3&K
Overrated games are overrated

Sonic 91 isn't overrated.

Zezima wrote:

NeoMetalSonic wrote:Oh f you

Because I made a joke, and like a game. Bravo. No prejudice at all.

NeoMetalSonic wrote:Some people actually DETEST that those games

1.- Proof.
2.- Who cares?
3.- "that those games" - That those games what? That those games are playable?

NeoMetalSonic wrote:Anyways
Sonic 1 and S3&K
Overrated games are overrated

Sonic 91 isn't overrated.

1.Sarcasm whats that?
2.I was making a statement and the games i was referring to were S3 & knuckles
3.How is it not?

NeoMetalSonic wrote:3.How is it not?

I haven't seen one person raging about how the original Sonic game is better than any other comparable video game in existence, and until I do, I don't see anything implying that it's overrated, or even highly regarded compared to the other games for that matter.

I didn't like CD. It's my least favorite of the original four. It doesn't help that Sonic 2 was released before it. (CD was supposed to be Sonic 2, but there were splits in management iirc. Naka headed up Sonic 2, while Oshima, I believe, headed up CD). And Sonic 2 was a buttload better than CD anyway, so I'd have to vote for CD being my least favorite.

Zezima wrote:

NeoMetalSonic wrote:3.How is it not?

I haven't seen one person raging about how the original Sonic game is better than any other comparable video game in existence, and until I do, I don't see anything implying that it's overrated, or even highly regarded compared to the other games for that matter.

Then you haven't met the people I met so lets leave it at that

NeoMetalSonic wrote:

Zez wrote:Someone's trolling. There's a vote for S3&K.

Oh f you
Some people actually DETEST that those games

Anyways
Sonic 1 and S3&K
Overrated games are overrated

Look at your comment, now back to mine. Look back at your comment, now back to mine. Sadly, it isn't mine. But if you stopped trolling and started posting legitimate comments, it could look like mine. Look down. Back up. Where are you? You're scrolling through comments, reading that comment your comment could look like. What did you post? Back to mine. It's a reply saying something you want to hear. Look again! The reply is now diamonds. Anything is possible when you post legit comments. I'm on a chair.

It was close between Sonic CD and Sonic 1, though ultimately I find Sonic CD worse.